Why is my planet in a different house? Whole-sign vs Bhava houses, measured

Answer. Because house systems draw the house boundaries in different places, a planet often lands in a neighbouring house. In 200,000 random charts (1950–2009, seven cities), a planet's house differed from its whole-sign house in 24.8% of placements under Bhava Chalit (equal houses with the Lagna degree at the middle of the 1st house), 30.8% under Sripati and 53.0% under Placidus. Under Bhava Chalit, 78% of charts had at least one of the nine grahas in a different house.

By AstroSutra · Published 17 November 2026 · Last updated 17 November 2026 · Swiss Ephemeris, Lahiri ayanamsa · Data: CSV · JSON · CC BY 4.0

Key findings

  1. In 200,000 random charts (1950–2009, seven cities, sidereal Lahiri), a planet's Bhava Chalit house (equal houses, Lagna degree at the middle of the 1st house) differed from its whole-sign house in 24.8% of placements.
  2. In 200,000 random charts (1950–2009), 77.8% had at least one of the nine grahas in a different house under Bhava Chalit than under whole-sign houses.
  3. In 200,000 random charts (1950–2009), a planet's Sripati house differed from its whole-sign house in 30.8% of placements, and its Placidus house (as used in KP) in 53.0%.
  4. Under Placidus house cusps, 93.3% of 200,000 random charts (1950–2009) had at least one of the nine grahas in a different house than under whole-sign houses.
  5. The Bhava Chalit difference is about 25% in every city, from Singapore to London, because it depends only on the planet's and the Lagna's degrees; Sripati and Placidus differ more at higher latitudes (Sripati: 25.4% of placements in Singapore, 40.7% in London).
  6. When a planet's house changes between whole-sign houses and Placidus cusps, it moves to the previous house in 89.8% of cases, because a Placidus house begins at its cusp degree rather than at the start of the sign.

The four systems

System Where the 1st house begins Where AstroSutra uses it
Whole sign 0° of the Lagna sign; each sign is one house Parashari birth chart, yogas, Manglik
Bhava Chalit (equal) 15° before the Lagna degree; every house 30° Computed with every chart, for planets near a house boundary
Sripati Halfway between the 12th and 1st bhava madhyas; the quadrants are split in three (Porphyry) Not used; measured for comparison
Placidus The Lagna degree itself; the quadrants are split by time KP charts and KP Prashna

How often a planet changes house

Compared with whole-sign houses Placements in a different house Charts with at least one planet moved
Bhava Chalit (equal, Lagna mid-house) 24.8% 77.8%
Sripati 30.8% 82.8%
Placidus (KP) 53.0% 93.3%

Placements are the nine grahas (Sun to Saturn, Rahu, Ketu) in each of 200,000 charts.

How many planets move in one chart

Planets in a different house Bhava Chalit Sripati Placidus
None 22.2% 17.2% 6.7%
1 19.6% 18.1% 9.5%
2 17.8% 16.6% 10.5%
3 15.2% 14.2% 10.6%
4 or more 25.2% 33.8% 62.7%

By city

City (latitude) Bhava Chalit Sripati Placidus
Singapore (1.4° N) 25.0% 25.4% 50.3%
Chennai (13.1° N) 25.0% 25.9% 50.5%
Mumbai (19.1° N) 24.7% 26.5% 51.0%
Delhi (28.6° N) 24.8% 28.6% 51.9%
New York (40.7° N) 24.9% 33.4% 54.0%
Toronto (43.7° N) 24.7% 35.0% 54.8%
London (51.5° N) 24.8% 40.7% 58.2%

About 28,600 charts (about 257,000 placements) per city; each cell's 95% confidence interval is within ±0.5 points.

Why the numbers come out this way

Under Bhava Chalit every house is 30° wide and centred on the Lagna degree plus a multiple of 30°. A planet changes house when it is more than 15° from that centre within its sign, which for evenly spread positions happens one time in four: hence about 25% in every city.

Placidus starts each house at its cusp, so a planet in the Lagna sign but at a lower degree than the Lagna falls in the 12th house. That alone moves about half of all placements to the previous house. Sripati and Placidus also divide the sky by quadrants, whose sizes depend on latitude, so their houses grow more unequal, and differ more from whole signs, the farther the birth place is from the equator.

Which one should you read?

They answer different questions in different traditions. Parashari astrology usually reads the whole-sign chart for most purposes and consults Bhava Chalit for planets near a house boundary; KP reads Placidus cusps. A planet that moves house between whole-sign houses and Bhava Chalit (or Sripati) sits near a sign or house boundary, and its house reading is the least certain part of the chart. Between whole-sign houses and Placidus, even a planet in the middle of a sign often moves to the previous house, because Placidus starts each house at its cusp degree. Two apps that disagree about a planet's house are often both computing correctly, with different systems.

Method

Item Value
Sample 200,000 birth moments, uniform to the minute, UTC 1950-01-01 to 2009-12-31, seed 20261118, rotating over seven cities
Positions Swiss Ephemeris, sidereal, Lahiri ayanamsa, true node; Ketu opposite Rahu
Whole sign and Bhava Chalit charts._get_whole_sign_house_number and charts._get_chalit_house_number, the functions AstroSutra's charts use
Sripati and Placidus Swiss Ephemeris house cusps (system 'S' and 'P'), shifted by the same ayanamsa as the planets; a planet's house is the cusp interval it lies in. House membership does not depend on which ayanamsa is used, as long as cusps and planets use the same one, so these shares also hold for KP's ayanamsa
Self-check The Placidus 1st cusp equals the Lagna in every chart (maximum difference 0.0°); no chart failed
Reproduce backend/scripts/geo_research_wave2.py houses --n 200000

Limitations

Frequently asked questions

Why is my planet in a different house in another app? Most often the two apps use different house systems. In 200,000 random charts, a planet's house differed between whole-sign houses and Bhava Chalit in 24.8% of placements, Sripati in 30.8% and Placidus in 53.0%. Check which system each app states before assuming one is wrong.

What is Bhava Chalit? A house system in which the calculated house points mark the middle of each house rather than its start, so houses straddle sign boundaries. It is computed either with equal 30° houses centred on the Lagna degree, as AstroSutra does, or with unequal Sripati houses. Under the equal version a planet's Chalit house differs from its whole-sign house about one time in four.

How often does a planet change house in the Bhava Chalit chart? In 24.8% of placements across 200,000 random charts, and 77.8% of charts have at least one of the nine grahas in a different Chalit house. The rate is about the same at every latitude.

Why does KP astrology put my planets in different houses? KP uses Placidus cusps, where each house starts at the cusp degree. In 200,000 random charts, 53.0% of placements were in a different Placidus house than whole-sign house, and in 89.8% of those the planet moved to the previous house.

Which house system does AstroSutra use? Whole-sign houses from the Lagna for the Parashari chart, Bhava Chalit houses for planets near house boundaries, and Placidus cusps with the KP ayanamsa for KP charts and KP Prashna. See how AstroSutra calculates.


How to cite: AstroSutra (2026). "Why is my planet in a different house? Whole-sign vs Bhava houses, measured." https://astrosutra.app/research/whole-sign-vs-bhava-houses/

Compute yours: a free AstroSutra chart shows your Lagna and the degree of every planet, so you can see which planets sit near a house boundary. Create a free chart. No payment.